Launch Slideshow

A Century-Old Dispute About Saws

A Century-Old Dispute About Saws

  • http://www.toolsofthetrade.net/Images/1600713316_Frane_Century-Old%20Dispute_1_tcm80-2079816.jpg?width=600

    true

    600

    Toolemera Press

    The Langdon Acme Miter Box was available in three sizes and came with a specially made Disston handsaw. The least expensive model cost $10; the most expensive $14.50.

  • http://www.toolsofthetrade.net/Images/1897978588_Frane_Century-Old%20Dispute_2_tcm80-2079817.jpg?width=600

    true

    600

    Toolemera Press

    Standard miter boxes of the day could cut 0 to 45 degrees. The New Langdon Miter Box Improved could cut 0 to 75 degrees. How? Look closely at the right hand fence and you’ll see an adjustable piece that pushes the material away from the fence so that when you swing the saw to 45 degrees you’re actually cutting 75 degrees. That round thing behind the fence is the lock knob. Okay smart guys at the power tool companies – why aren’t you doing this with miter saws?

  • http://www.toolsofthetrade.net/Images/1738566227_Frane_Century-Old%20Dispute_3_tcm80-2079818.jpg?width=600

    true

    600

    Toolemera Press

    The notes below this Langdon Adjustable Miter Box say that if you send them your saw the company will fit it to the miter box for free. But they’ll charge you if the saw’s messed up and they have to fix it. It sounds reasonable to me.

  • http://www.toolsofthetrade.net/Images/1885913228_Frane_Century-Old%20Dispute_4_tcm80-2079819.jpg?width=600

    true

    600

    Toolemera Press

    The New Langdon Miter Box at the top of the page is guaranteed to make perfect cuts when used with the supplied back saw. The Star Miter Box at the bottom of page is budget model – better than a wood miter box but not as good as the miter boxes in previous photos. It cost $2.

In a Lost Art Press blog entry, Christopher Schwartz recounts the story of a labor dispute that took place in Chicago in 1901. It had to do with the patent miter box–an adjustable metal frame used to guide handsaws while making miter cuts. At the time of the dispute, the norm for most carpenters was to use a wood miter box, which was lighter and cheaper but far less accurate than a metal one.

The dispute was over a Carpenter's Union rule that forbade members from bringing their own patent miter boxes to work, on the theory that if one carpenter brought one, pretty soon every carpenter would have to bring one and that would work a hardship on members. Why? Patent miter boxes were more expensive, heavier, and more difficult to transport than wood ones, and likely to be stolen if left overnight on the jobsite (hmm … sounds a lot like modern miter saws).

Testifying before a government official, union carpenter O.E. Woodbury said the union's position was that if the bosses wanted carpenters to use metal miter boxes, they should provide them. The tradition obviously took hold, because it's still more or less the norm on jobsites (both union and non-union) for the employer to provide certain large tools (miter saws, table saws, and the like) for employees to use.

The miter boxes shown on the left side of this page are from the 1904 Millers Falls Catalog (Photos courtesy of the Toolemera Press).